Civil Society to Carney: Intercede on Bill C-22 before it’s too late
A letter from 26 leading rights, refugee and privacy experts and organizations urges the Prime Minister to back targeted Senate amendments, warning Bill C-22 threatens his ambition for a sovereign Canadian economy integrated with Europe.
November 19th, 2026 — Today, OpenMedia and 25 leading civil liberties, refugee rights and privacy organizations and experts delivered a joint letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney, asking him to intercede in the Senate’s ongoing consideration of Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act. The Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs (SECD) is currently hearing from its final round of witnesses before considering amendments and a final vote, which may occur before its December recess. Signatories say the Prime Minister is the one person who can still ensure critical changes are made to dangerously ill-considered legislation.
The House made limited amendments to Bill C-22 before passing it to the Senate, cutting the metadata retention period from one year to six months and adding a narrow clause limiting compelled decryption. But signatories warn the changes leave the bill’s most dangerous architecture intact: the power to force providers to retain metadata on everyone in Canada or abroad, and the power for the Minister of Public Safety to issue secret orders compelling any electronic service to build government access into its systems.
The letter argues these two provisions directly undercut the government’s own priorities. Population-wide metadata retention and secret access orders are out of step with European and international human rights standards, putting Canada’s GDPR adequacy status and its ambition to become the EU’s first associate member at risk. They threaten the privacy-first services Canadians rely on as alternatives to U.S. Big Tech – services the government would like to see adopted as components of Canadian digital sovereignty. And by undermining private communication, they put some of the most marginalized communities in Canada at greater risk, such as survivors of intimate partner violence, human rights defenders, and diaspora communities facing transnational repression.
Bill C-22 is the government’s second attempt to pass these powers. They first appeared in Bill C-2, the so-called “Strong Borders Act,” in June 2025, which would have let police and CSIS demand information about people’s online accounts without a warrant. More than 300 civil society organizations joined OpenMedia in demanding its complete withdrawal, and in October 2025 the government dropped lawful access from its border legislation. It reintroduced the provisions as a standalone bill, C-22, in March 2026, with the most dangerous part — now Part 2 — carried forward intact.
In today’s letter, signatories ask the Prime Minister to direct his Government Representative in the Senate to bring forward two key amendments: striking section 5(2)(d)’s power to require retention of metadata on all users, and forbidding any regulation or secret ministerial order that would require a provider to access, intercept or circumvent end-to-end encrypted communications. They argue this protection must be locked in legislative text, so a future Cabinet cannot redefine it away, and that all obligations should be subject to full judicial authorization and public by default.
The full letter and list of signatories is available in English and French here.
Quotes
“The Prime Minister wants to govern a sovereign Canada economically integrated with Europe, and whose values celebrate protecting people most at risk. Yet his own legislation undermines this vision. Europe will not integrate with an economy where apps can be secretly forced to backdoor their services — that’s against their laws and values, and it should be against ours. And no democracy should force basic services to keep a ‘filing cabinet’ of sensitive data on millions of its citizens suspected of no crime, just in case police want it one day.”
— Matt Hatfield, Executive Director, OpenMedia, a community-based organization that works to keep the Internet open, affordable, and surveillance-free.
“At a time when criminals are using AI technologies to find and exploit vulnerabilities faster than ever, Canada needs strong encryption, no exceptions. Bill C-22 opens a Pandora’s box of problems that risks leaving Canadians more exposed to hackers, scams, identity theft and foreign surveillance. There is no back door that only the good guys can walk through. The Prime Minister can keep the Canadian flag from becoming a warning label for insecurity: protect encryption and drop the bill’s dangerous data-retention rules.”
— Natalie Campbell, Senior Director, North American Government and Regulatory Affairs, the Internet Society, a global non-profit organization working to ensure the Internet is for everyone.
Press Contacts
Matt Hatfield
Executive Director, OpenMedia
1 (888) 441-2640 ext. 0
[email protected]
Natalie Campbell
Senior Director, North American Government and Regulatory Affairs
1 (514) 269-1912
[email protected]